Writing a commentary on an article

Criteria for acceptance include clarity and coherence of the position espoused, technical soundness, and reviewer judgment as to the degree to which the commentary contributes to greater insight and understanding of the topic.

Make sure there is full author information name, affiliation, address, phone, email for all authors. Every journal has specific requirements of word limit, abstract, headings, tables and figures, number of references, etc.

How to Write a Book Commentary

Going as light as possible on references provides more space for commentaries. Do not include general praise for the focal article. We will use a variety of strategies in such a circumstance. A effective commentary offers positive feedback that lets the creator determine what is working.

The publisher reserves the right to charge authors for correction of non-typographical errors. The goal of the focal article-commentary format is to advance the field by providing a forum for varying perspectives on the topic under consideration.

Guidelines for writing a commentary

Source material might include trade journals, books or academic essays on the subject. In summary, a commentary may be: Create a narrow your quest of items you have to critique or mention in your commentary.

These include editing one section of a broad commentary to eliminate the section redundant with another commentary, and working with the authors to pool their efforts and produce a joint commentary.

It is very important to go through the author guidelines carefully and ensure that all these requirements have been met before submission. Review process Commentaries will be peer reviewed and most likely accepted if they are in line with the definitions and guidelines outlined.

What is a commentary? This means you should keep a professional writing approach based on research and facts -- not just personal opinion. Do not include general praise for the focal article.

An application of a theoretical or methodological perspective that sheds light on the issues addressed in the focal article. Your commentary should be between four and six double-spaced pages, plus a title page.

Write an essay about your favorite food and drink recipe Write an essay about your favorite food and drink recipe zoo essay words raksha bandhan in hindi 10 page essay question cbse social science page essay ul fitr questions essay writing service bid used customer 20 page essay lines republic day word essay uses minimum wages 14th amendment essay worksheet answers key good research paper topics for english ideas lines essay republic day how to write a good word essay one night write an essay about your birthday card for brother's 21st birthday words essay on newspaper kalamazoo michigan.

Use only essential citations.SCENARIO. In the halcyon days after completion of your thesis, you attended a conference on evidence-based practice and signed up to become a commentator for Evidence-Based agronumericus.com, 4 months later, you have received an email request from the journal inviting you to write a commentary.

Examples of Commentary. Commentary can be a hard concept to understand without examples to guide you.

How to write a commentary paper on an article

Beside the wonderful examples and explanations presented in Richard Straub's and Summer Smith's articles, I have included links to some of my own commentary and the papers on which those comments were based.

Nov 14,  · Help writing college admission essay class 12th essay writing service pro the uk student room 10 page essay quote questions short essay on my favorite book in hindi ramayanam 10 page research paper rubric grade 4th, write an essay about your birthday card for mom cool 20 page essay lines per inch graph paper sheet how to write a great essay introduction lit how to write better.

MELAB Sample Essays and Commentary 1 Contents On the following pages are ten MELAB essays representative of each score on the MELAB Writing Rating Scale.

Commentaries follow each sample essay. A condensed version of the rating scale is available on page Commentary Notes Writing commentary means giving your opinion, interpretation, insight, analysis, explication, personal reaction, evaluation or reflection about a concrete detail in an essay.

You are "commenting on" a point you have made. Writing commentary is higher level thinking. Literature commentary has some rules: • do not use I, me, my, we, us, • avoid using would, should, could, mayor might Literature commentary discusses what the concrete detail shows about a character or event in a story.

If you get stuck writing commentary, start your commentary sentences with This shows that _ The result will almost always be commentary.

Writing a commentary on an article
Rated 5/5 based on 96 review